A Simple Nullity? PDF ePub eBook

Books Info:

A Simple Nullity? free pdf In 1877, the NZ Supreme Court decided the case of Wi Parata v Bishop of Wellington, centred on the ownership and use of the Whitireia Block near Porirua, which had been granted by Ngati Toa to the Anglican Church for a school that was never built. Refusing jurisdiction over the case, the Court also denied the legal relevance of the Treaty of Waitangi in NZ law. The judges wrote, "So far indeed as that instrument purported to cede the sovereignty - a matter with which we are not directly concerned - it must be regarded as a simple nullity." Over the past 20 years, judges, lawyers and commentators have castigated the "simple nullity" view of the Treaty in this "infamous" case as a sign of the historic neglect of Maori rights by settlers, government, and the law in New Zealand. The case was used as a point of reference, in order to repudiate it, in the major Ngati Apa case that led to the Foreshore and Seabed legislation. Williams takes a fresh look at Wi Parata with insights into Maori/Pakeha relations and into the legal meaning of the Treaty. The case, he argues, tells us much about the power of 19th-century Maori as agents and about debates in Pakeha jurisprudence over the different potential legal sources of customary Maori rights (jure gentium and aboriginal title). Behind the apparent dismissal of the Treaty as a "simple nullity" lay deep arguments about Maori and Pakeha in Aotearoa NZ.

About David V. Williams

David V Williams is Professor of Law at The University of Auckland. He has been a Treaty researcher for many years and is author of "Te Kooti tango whenua": The Native Land Court 1864-1909 (Huia) and co-editor of Waitangi Revisited: Perspectives on the Treaty of Waitangi (OUP, 2005).

Details Book

Author : David V. Williams
Publisher : Auckland University Press
Data Published : 01 June 2011
ISBN : 186940484X
EAN : 9781869404840
Format Book : PDF, Epub, DOCx, TXT
Number of Pages : 304 pages
Age + : 15 years
Language : English
Rating :

Reviews A Simple Nullity?



17 Comments Add a comment




Related eBooks Download


  • Simple Nullity?, A free pdfSimple Nullity?, A

    David V. Williams takes a fresh look at the notorious Wi Parata case - the protagonists. the origins of the dispute. the years of legal back and forth - affording new insights into both Maori-Pakeha relations in the nineteenth century and the legal position of the Treaty of Waitangi..


  • Exploring Maori Values free pdfExploring Maori Values

    This book offers Pakeha New Zealanders an insight into Maori thought and values and the basis for the sort of understanding and partnership that should exist between Pakeha and Maori..


  • Te Mana o Te Tiriti - the Living Treaty free pdfTe Mana o Te Tiriti - the Living Treaty

    The Treaty of Waitangi signed in 1840. is the subject of much discussion. writing and debate. Europeans are often surprised by the interest. Maori are not surprised because for them this has always been a living treaty that documents the rights agreed last century..


  • Plays Maori and Pakeha, Vol. 2 free pdfPlays Maori and Pakeha, Vol. 2

    Excerpt from Plays Maori and Pakeha. Vol. 2 Scene: A New Zealand forest-trees. ferns. undergrowth. etc. In the foreground crouches a slave keeping careful look-out..


  • Power without Law free pdfPower without Law

    The Supreme Court of Canada's decision in the Marshall case asserted sweeping Native treaty rights and intense controversy. In "Power without Law" Alex Cameron enlivens the debate over judicial activism with an unprecedented examination of the details of the Marshall case..


  • A Simple Nullity? free pdfA Simple Nullity?

    . In 1877, the NZ Supreme Court decided the case of Wi Parata v Bishop of Wellington, centred on the ownership and use of the Whitireia Block near Porirua, which had been granted by Ngati Toa to the A